The answer I marked wrong fitted the question I had actually written
EducationA student put the question beside her answer and asked me to read both aloud.
I had intended students to compare two processes. The wording asked them to describe one. Her answer did exactly that, and my comment said the comparison was missing.
For a moment I wanted to explain what we had practiced all week. That would explain my intention, not the instruction she had received.
I told her I needed to review the question across the class before deciding the correction. I do not want to repair only the paper belonging to the student confident enough to challenge me.
The replacement prompt now asks explicitly for the comparison. The old one stays in my assessment notes beside her answer.
She did not discover a clever loophole. She read a sentence more faithfully than the person who wrote it.