Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Sports ·

Someone found my disc and sent me a price list before an address

Sports category photographSports

The photo in the message showed my disc, my phone number, and the words 'Found it. Ten dollars for retrieval.'

I had lost it during a disc golf round two days earlier. It was an ordinary disc with a dented edge, but I had finally learned how it flew. I was happy enough to see it that I almost sent the money immediately.

Then I asked where it had been found. The person said he searches the wooded sections near the course and charges for anything he returns. He had not been searching for mine at my request. I offered to collect it at the course or meet somewhere convenient. He repeated the price.

A friend says ten dollars is less than replacing it and that I should reward the effort. Another says paying makes a surprise fee seem normal. I am caught between those arguments while a stranger holds the only copy of a small thing I liked.

I would happily have offered coffee money if he had just contacted me. Being invoiced before saying hello feels different.

I have not replied yet. The cheapest choice may be paying. I am less sure it would leave me feeling as though I got my disc back.

Discussion

5 community replies

You are not objecting to thanking him. You are objecting to discovering that the return has a price after someone else has possession of the disc.

Searching wooded areas can take real time. He may see this as a service, even though you never asked him to provide one.

That can explain his price without establishing that the owner agreed to buy the service. Keeping those two points separate avoids arguing about whether his afternoon had value.

Ask the course operator whether it has a lost-disc arrangement before negotiating further. There may be a simple return point both of you can use.

The dented edge makes this more than a price comparison with a new disc. Familiar equipment can be worth keeping without being worth a stranger's surprise fee.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Sports

Explore more Sports stories →