Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Education ·

Our service-learning slideshow needed a smiling photo, and I did not want to ask for one

Education category photographEducation

The slide template had a box labeled “Community impact.” My group wanted a photograph of someone receiving supplies at the pantry where we volunteered.

We had helped carry boxes and sort donations. We had not been told we could photograph visitors. One teammate said we should just ask someone to smile because the assignment needed proof we had made a difference.

I was uncomfortable before I could explain why. A person arriving for supplies should not have to become our evidence of being helpful.

We asked the pantry coordinator what documentation was permitted and told the instructor what the template seemed to require. There may be a suitable way to describe the work without including recipients at all.

I also need to narrow the claim. We can explain the tasks we completed. A photograph would not prove what difference those tasks made in someone else’s life.

For now, the slide has our sorting notes where the smiling person was supposed to go.

Discussion

5 community replies

Your discomfort connects to a real choice the visitor would face. The class needs evidence of your learning; that does not automatically make a visitor responsible for providing it.

What did the instructor mean by community impact in the template? Clarifying the intended evidence could solve the assignment problem without asking visitors for anything.

A photograph can show a moment. It cannot establish the broader outcome your group was about to attach to it. Keeping the claim limited matters either way.

Record the tasks, time, and instructions you actually followed, then ask which permitted materials can accompany that account. Those are details the group can verify.

And do not turn the sorting notes into a larger impact claim just because the picture is gone. The wording needs the same restraint.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Education

Explore more Education stories →