Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Education ·

Our lab results looked wrong, so my partner began making them look right

Education category photographEducation

My lab partner crossed out our third measurement and wrote a number closer to the other two.

“We obviously read it wrong,” he said.

Maybe we had. We were using unfamiliar equipment in an introductory class, and our notes were messy. But we had not repeated the measurement or found an error. We had only found a result we disliked.

I stopped him, then immediately felt ridiculous for making such a serious face over a classroom exercise. He said he wanted a usable graph, not a research scandal.

The instructor came over when we asked. She told us to keep the original readings visible and explain our uncertainty. We repeated what we could within the time left. The graph stayed untidy.

Writing the discussion afterward was harder than replacing the number would have been. We had to say what we observed, what we suspected, and what we could not establish.

My partner still thinks I made extra work for us. He is correct about the extra work. I do not think that settles the argument.

Discussion

5 community replies

An odd reading and a demonstrated reading error are different. Keeping the original lets the explanation reflect which one you actually have.

“A usable graph” was doing a lot of work in that conversation. Usable for earning a tidy mark, or usable for showing what happened?

In the write-up, keep the repeat reading separate from the original. Otherwise the second attempt could quietly erase the same uncertainty again.

He may have assumed the assignment rewarded matching the expected pattern. The instructor should make clear how honest irregular results are assessed.

That would help without excusing the change. Students should not have to guess whether an honest messy graph will be treated as careless work.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Education

Explore more Education stories →