Our film-club copy quietly removed the scene we planned to discuss
EntertainmentOur film club paused after a family argument because the next scene was the reason I had chosen the movie. Instead, the copy jumped to breakfast, where everyone was suddenly speaking kindly again.
Half the group called the reconciliation unearned. I remembered a conversation on a railway platform, but it was not in the version we had rented. The running time on our screen was eleven minutes shorter than the edition I knew.
We could finish the available cut and discuss what it actually contained, or stop while I searched for another licensed copy. The café had forty minutes left on our booking, so we watched the shorter ending and treated the missing scene as part of the conversation.
People who had never seen the longer version judged the breakfast on its own. Those who had remembered how much work eleven absent minutes had been doing.
I chose the film for one scene. Its absence gave the club a different subject than the one I had prepared.