Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Sports ·

Our championship trophy has the wrong team name, and I am the one who approved the proof

Sports category photographSports

We turned the trophy toward the camera and saw our rivals' name on the plaque.

I had ordered it after our bowling team won its division. The engraver sent a proof during my lunch break. I checked the year and player names, glanced at the top line, and replied that it looked good. The rival team's name was already there.

The engraver will replace the plate for thirty dollars. I can afford it. The problem is that everyone thinks the shop made the mistake, and two teammates have started leaving angry comments on its page.

I said I was handling it. That bought me a day of not admitting what the email shows. I keep imagining the shop posting the approved proof underneath our complaints.

Our captain offered to go down there and demand a refund. I finally told her to wait because I had signed off on the wrong name. She stared, then laughed so hard she had to sit down.

I am paying for the plate and asking the others to remove their comments. We have agreed to keep one photo of the original. Winning the division was impressive; briefly awarding it to the rivals was entirely my contribution.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell the teammates who complained that the incorrect proof came to you and you approved it. They need that fact directly, rather than hearing only that the plaque is being fixed.

Your rivals may never mount a more efficient title campaign than the one you ran during lunch.

The shop supplied a proof with an error too. That does not justify the complaints, but taking responsibility does not require pretending the first mistake was yours alone.

Agreed. The truthful account is that the name was wrong in the proof and you missed it. Let the shop discuss the fee on that basis instead of defending an invented version.

The captain laughing was probably the most generous result available. Now the wrong plate can become a team joke rather than a business dispute.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Sports

Explore more Sports stories →