Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Sports ·

Our captain's player ratings were supposed to help him pick teams, until he shared the sheet

Sports category photographSports

My name had a four beside 'decision-making' and a note saying I panicked under pressure.

Our rec basketball captain had made ratings to balance teams during practice. I knew he kept notes. I did not know he planned to send everyone the spreadsheet, complete with comments about confidence, fitness, and who could be trusted late in a game.

He called it transparency. Within an hour, teammates were comparing numbers. One player asked why a six was passing instructions to an eight. Another stopped replying. I wanted to dispute my four and hated that this was my first reaction.

The captain says we need honest feedback if we want to improve. I would have welcomed one private observation about a specific possession. A public score turned that conversation into defending my place in the group.

I asked him to remove the shared sheet and discuss feedback individually. He said hiding it would make the ratings seem shameful.

They already feel shameful. I am trying to explain that the problem is not whether four is an accurate number. It is that we suddenly have a ranking system where yesterday we had teammates.

Discussion

5 community replies

The joke about a six instructing an eight shows the sheet already doing a job beyond balancing practice teams.

A captain may need to assess players. Publishing the assessments with personal comments is a separate choice from making them.

Exactly. Keeping selection notes private would not mean nobody receives feedback. It would change the audience and make room for an actual conversation.

Wanting to argue your four is a very believable first reaction. The ranking pulls you into its terms before you can question why it exists.

Ask him to discuss the possession that led to the panic comment. That is feedback you can use without accepting a public label as your identity.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Sports

Explore more Sports stories →