Our captain's player ratings were supposed to help him pick teams, until he shared the sheet
SportsMy name had a four beside 'decision-making' and a note saying I panicked under pressure.
Our rec basketball captain had made ratings to balance teams during practice. I knew he kept notes. I did not know he planned to send everyone the spreadsheet, complete with comments about confidence, fitness, and who could be trusted late in a game.
He called it transparency. Within an hour, teammates were comparing numbers. One player asked why a six was passing instructions to an eight. Another stopped replying. I wanted to dispute my four and hated that this was my first reaction.
The captain says we need honest feedback if we want to improve. I would have welcomed one private observation about a specific possession. A public score turned that conversation into defending my place in the group.
I asked him to remove the shared sheet and discuss feedback individually. He said hiding it would make the ratings seem shameful.
They already feel shameful. I am trying to explain that the problem is not whether four is an accurate number. It is that we suddenly have a ranking system where yesterday we had teammates.