Our apartment directory lists dogs before people, and one tenant cannot get his name added
Stories & ConfessionsOur doorman remembers every dog in the building.
When I moved in, he wrote “Mabel — with Chris, 5C” in his notebook. Other entries followed the same pattern: Pepper with June, Otis with the Parkers.
Residents found it charming. Management turned the notebook into a printed lobby directory titled “Dogs and Their People.”
Delivery workers use it. Children use it. New tenants are introduced through their pets.
Then Daniel moved into 8A without a dog. The directory listed only “8A — no dog yet.” His name was omitted from three editions despite repeated requests.
Packages have been returned because drivers could not match Daniel to the apartment. He says the joke now makes him less visible in his own home.
Management wants to add a standard resident directory beside the dog version. Daniel wants the novelty directory removed entirely.
We let a warm doorman habit become the building’s official way of recognizing people.
Can the dog directory stay once it has caused someone practical harm?