One loose annotation revealed what my friend thought of my favorite chapter
EntertainmentMy friend lent me her novel for book club with small paper tabs covering every handwritten note. She said she wanted me to meet the book before meeting her opinions.
On my favorite chapter, one cover slip fell out. Under it she had written, “Beautiful sentences, completely dishonest narrator.” I had been preparing to praise that narrator’s honesty at the meeting.
I could put the tab back and pretend I had not seen it, or ask her before the group discussion changed the comment into a public disagreement. I sent her a photograph of the exposed line and said I had found it by accident.
She replied that the note was exactly why she had covered the margins, then asked me not to soften my view because of hers. At the meeting, we disagreed about the narrator and did not mention the loose tab.
Her opinion arrived early. It did not have to speak first.