Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Family ·

My uncle created a family jury for arguments between cousins

Family category photographFamily

After two cousins argued over a borrowed tent, Uncle Ray emailed seven relatives announcing that we had been selected as the “family jury.”

He attached statements from both cousins and set a video hearing for Thursday. Neither cousin had asked him to mediate, and I had not agreed to judge them.

The tent can be returned or replaced directly. Turning the dispute into a family proceeding spreads it to people who were not involved.

I declined the invitation and deleted the statements. I told both cousins I would speak to them as family, not issue a verdict.

Ray says neutral relatives are the only way to prevent grudges.

Mediation can help when the people in conflict choose it. A jury created by a third relative adds an audience before it adds a solution.

Discussion

5 community replies

Decline the hearing and ask your uncle not to circulate private statements about disputes you are not handling.

You can remain available for separate supportive conversations without accepting authority to decide the outcome.

Your uncle may be trying to create a fair process rather than take sides. A process is not neutral when the participants never consented to it.

The jury model risks making a replaceable tent into a lasting public record of blame.

Do the two cousins want any mediator, or did the entire procedure originate with your uncle?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Family

Explore more Family stories →