Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Sports ·

My teammate wanted his error changed to a hit, and asked me to be his witness

Sports category photographSports

He sent the clip with the message, 'Tell them that was impossible to field.' I had watched the ball go between his legs from ten feet away.

Our adult baseball league keeps individual statistics. The scorer recorded an error on my teammate. He thinks the bounce was awkward enough that it should not count against him and has asked for a review.

I do remember a bad hop. I also remember having time to think he was about to field it cleanly. Those memories do not make me an official scorer. What bothers me is that he wants a firm statement I cannot honestly give.

He says teammates should back one another. I offered to describe the bounce and where I was standing. He replied that an uncertain witness would not help.

The game result will not change. This is about his fielding record, which matters to him more than I realized. I am trying not to mock that. I care about numbers too when they flatter me.

I have sent the plain description. If supporting him requires remembering the play more confidently than I do, I cannot provide that particular support.

Discussion

5 community replies

The description of the hop and your position is useful evidence precisely because it does not pretend you made the scoring decision.

And it is fine to say what you cannot tell from the clip. More detail is not the same as more certainty.

You are taking his concern seriously without borrowing his certainty. That may feel unsupportive to him while the number is bothering him.

He is allowed to request a review if the league offers one. Asking a teammate to supply a conclusion rather than their observation is the part to resist.

'An uncertain witness would not help' suggests he wanted reinforcement more than recollection. Your account can still help whoever is actually reviewing it.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Sports

Explore more Sports stories →