My son's project partner took his name off the part they disagreed about
ParentingMy twelve-year-old showed me a shared class poster. His name had disappeared from the section he'd written.
His partner had changed that section. My son had said he preferred the first version. The partner told him he couldn't have his name on it if he didn't agree.
I immediately suggested doing a separate poster.
My son said the assignment was in pairs. He wanted to fix the disagreement, not begin a second project on Thursday night.
I had supplied an exit before asking what he actually wanted.
He still likes working with this classmate. He also wants the work he did acknowledged. I don't know their teacher's expectations about the format or how much of the conversation happened exactly as he remembers it. I have the poster and his account.
I asked him to show me the previous section and explain which change bothered him. It was a sentence about what their observations meant. He wasn't sure the new conclusion followed.
We didn't settle the scientific question at our table. He wrote down what he wanted to ask his partner and what he would need to ask the teacher if they couldn't agree.
Then he asked whether I thought telling the teacher was tattling.
I said asking how to complete a paired assignment was different from demanding that the other child be punished. He could be specific about the disagreement rather than describing the partner as impossible.
He hasn't sent the question yet. He wants to try speaking to the classmate first.
The poster is still shared. I am trying not to draft a second version in my head while he decides how to keep it that way.