Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Parenting ·

My son has already blown out birthday candles and doesn't want to do it again here

Parenting category photographParenting

My son turned ten at his dad's house. They had cake, sang and sent me a photograph. He came to mine the next evening.

I'd bought another cake. When I brought it out, he asked if we could eat it without singing.

I said I hadn't had my turn celebrating him. He said he didn't mind eating cake with me. He didn't want another round of everyone looking at him while he blew.

I heard the request as a comparison between households. He was making a distinction between dessert and being the center of a ceremony for the second time.

The candles were still in the drawer. Nothing had to be unlit or performed. I could put plates on the table and have the evening he'd said he'd enjoy.

I did. I also felt sad about missing the first cake. Both things were possible while we ate.

He told me what his sister had said during the song at Dad's. I laughed without asking him to reproduce the rest of the event. Later we looked at the card I'd given him.

Next year we may make different arrangements. There is no reason to negotiate the whole future of birthdays over a cake somebody is already happy to eat.

The unused candles are beside the measuring cups. I haven't made them into evidence that my birthday evening didn't count.

Discussion

5 community replies

He accepted the shared cake and declined a repeat ceremony. Treating those as one offer would have hidden the part he actually wanted with you.

Missing the first song can hurt without becoming something he has to repair by performing a second one. You made room for your own disappointment without asking him to host it.

A future year might need a conversation about plans. That doesn't mean this evening's request was a binding decision about every birthday from now on.

Make that conversation when there's an actual next plan to arrange. The unopened candle package wasn't a deadline for settling it.

Did he usually enjoy the singing, or was doing it twice what changed his preference this time? If you ask later, leave room for either answer.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Parenting

Explore more Parenting stories →