Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Family ·

My sister asked the children to grade every adult after the holiday visit

Family category photographFamily

On the drive home, my daughter showed me a form asking her to score each adult relative for patience, generosity and fun.

My sister had given copies to all the cousins. She planned to announce the highest-rated adult at the next family dinner as a way to encourage better behavior around children.

The children should be able to tell us when something feels wrong. They should not be turned into judges whose scores become entertainment among adults.

I discarded the form and asked my daughter privately whether anything during the visit had bothered her.

My sister says anonymous ratings give children a voice.

A voice is not the same as a leaderboard. Listening requires safe conversation and follow-up, not a prize that adults may pressure children to influence.

Discussion

5 community replies

Stop the scoring exercise and invite children to share concerns privately with a trusted adult.

Discarding the form should be paired with a genuine check-in so the children do not hear that their opinions are unwanted.

Your sister may be trying to center children’s experiences in a family that usually centers adults. Public rankings are likely to distort the feedback she wants.

The strongest part of the idea is asking children how visits feel; the weakest is converting those answers into adult competition.

Were the forms truly anonymous, and who would have seen the completed ratings before the announcement?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Family

Explore more Family stories →