Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Relationships ·

My sister asked me to be a godparent, but I no longer believe the promises she wants me to make

Relationships category photographRelationships

My sister sent the words she wanted me to say at her baby's ceremony. I read them three times before calling her.

I love my niece and want to be part of her life. I cannot honestly promise to guide her in a faith I no longer practice.

My sister said everyone knows these ceremonies are also about family. She chose me because she trusts me, not because she expects a weekly religious lesson.

I asked whether the words could reflect that. She said changing them would upset her and turn the day into a statement about my beliefs.

I understand why she wants the tradition kept whole. I also dislike being told the promise is symbolic when I hesitate and important when I suggest changing it.

Our mother says I can say the words for the baby's sake and live out the loving part afterward. My sister says refusal would feel like stepping back from the child.

I have offered every kind of involvement I can mean. The one thing I cannot give comfortably is the exact sentence that would make everyone else comfortable.

Discussion

5 community replies

If the wording matters enough that it cannot change, honesty about the wording matters too. The narrator can love the child without making a religious promise they do not believe.

They should check what the actual ceremony requires rather than negotiate through assumptions. Any alternative needs to fit what the family and ceremony organizers will accept, not an invented workaround.

The sister hears an invitation into a family role being declined. Acknowledging that hurt may help more than arguing that she is inconsistent about symbolism, even if the contradiction is real.

Both seem to be protecting sincerity: the sister wants a tradition that feels whole, and the narrator wants a promise that feels true. There may be sadness even after an honest answer.

Offer a separate, concrete promise about being present in the niece's life. The sister may still choose someone else for the ceremony, but that need not determine the entire relationship.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Relationships

Explore more Relationships stories →