My sister asked me to be a godparent, but I no longer believe the promises she wants me to make
RelationshipsMy sister sent the words she wanted me to say at her baby's ceremony. I read them three times before calling her.
I love my niece and want to be part of her life. I cannot honestly promise to guide her in a faith I no longer practice.
My sister said everyone knows these ceremonies are also about family. She chose me because she trusts me, not because she expects a weekly religious lesson.
I asked whether the words could reflect that. She said changing them would upset her and turn the day into a statement about my beliefs.
I understand why she wants the tradition kept whole. I also dislike being told the promise is symbolic when I hesitate and important when I suggest changing it.
Our mother says I can say the words for the baby's sake and live out the loving part afterward. My sister says refusal would feel like stepping back from the child.
I have offered every kind of involvement I can mean. The one thing I cannot give comfortably is the exact sentence that would make everyone else comfortable.