Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Food ·

My Sister Asked for the Soup Recipe Before I Had Decided It Was Good

Food category photographFood

“Can you send me the recipe?” my sister asked.

I was still listing what I wanted to change. The carrot soup needed more ginger, or perhaps less orange. I had made it for lunch and spent half the meal mentally revising the bowl in front of me.

She took another spoonful and said she liked it as it was.

I almost explained why she should not. Then I heard myself beginning a sentence about the ginger and stopped. She was not asking for my ideal future soup. She wanted instructions for the one she had just eaten.

I sent the recipe with a note about the small changes I had actually made, leaving out the changes I had only considered. A week later she sent a picture of her pot.

It looked thicker than mine. She had used less liquid because that was what she preferred.

I had been so busy treating my own version as unfinished that it surprised me to see it become somebody else's starting point.

Discussion

5 community replies

She was giving you a specific kind of praise: she wanted to eat it again at her own table. Your private list of possible improvements did not have to accompany that.

Sending the changes you actually made preserved a usable account. Including every unrealized adjustment would have described a soup neither of you had tasted.

Your sister managed to enjoy lunch while you were still attending the soup's development meeting.

And then she made her own version without waiting for the meeting to finish. That seems like a healthier relationship with lunch.

Keep that note with the original recipe too. If someone asks for the same soup later, your memory of what really went into the pot may be less clear.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Food

Explore more Food stories →