Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Education ·

My self-portrait looked less like me after I followed everybody’s advice

Education category photographEducation

The first sketch had my uneven fringe and a tired expression. After three classmates offered improvements, the face had smooth hair, larger eyes, and no particular resemblance to me.

I had asked for feedback during art class. I had not asked myself which kind. Every suggestion sounded helpful because it gave me something definite to change.

The instructor asked what I wanted the portrait to communicate. I said I liked that the first one looked as if I had just come in from the bus. She asked why that was the part I had erased.

I have kept both versions. Next class I want feedback on whether the expression reads, rather than accepting every adjustment that makes a face look tidier.

My classmates were trying to help. The decision to turn my own face into a committee project was still mine.

Discussion

5 community replies

The bus expression gave the portrait something specific. Keeping the first sketch lets you recover that intention without declaring every later suggestion useless.

Were the classmates responding to likeness, technique, or what they found attractive? Those are different kinds of feedback to invite.

Naming the question before the critique would help everyone aim at the same thing. “What needs improvement?” left several goals competing.

A definite suggestion can feel easier to trust than your own unfinished intention. That does not mean it serves the piece you wanted to make.

Do not make the first sketch untouchable just because it felt personal. You can keep its expression and still revise a part that gets in the way.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Education

Explore more Education stories →