My self-portrait looked less like me after I followed everybody’s advice
EducationThe first sketch had my uneven fringe and a tired expression. After three classmates offered improvements, the face had smooth hair, larger eyes, and no particular resemblance to me.
I had asked for feedback during art class. I had not asked myself which kind. Every suggestion sounded helpful because it gave me something definite to change.
The instructor asked what I wanted the portrait to communicate. I said I liked that the first one looked as if I had just come in from the bus. She asked why that was the part I had erased.
I have kept both versions. Next class I want feedback on whether the expression reads, rather than accepting every adjustment that makes a face look tidier.
My classmates were trying to help. The decision to turn my own face into a committee project was still mine.