My peer-review partner gave me eight compliments and nothing I could revise
Education“Really interesting!” appeared beside my introduction. “Great detail!” sat next to a paragraph I already suspected was irrelevant. At the bottom, my peer-review partner wrote, “Would love to read more.”
The draft was already over the word limit.
She handed it back looking pleased, and I thanked her. Then I went home with the same question I had brought to class: which part of this essay should go?
We are reviewing each other's next drafts on Thursday. I could ask for blunt criticism, but I do not want to make kindness sound like a failure. I also remember being afraid that an honest comment would damage somebody's confidence.
I am thinking of putting one request at the top: “Please mark the first place you lose track of my argument, even if you like the writing.” It gives her permission to notice a problem without requiring her to judge the entire paper.
I will still need to return the favor. Last week I wrote “nice flow” on her draft, which is apparently what happens when two nervous people exchange homework and try to remain friends.