Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Education ·

My peer-review partner gave me eight compliments and nothing I could revise

Education category photographEducation

“Really interesting!” appeared beside my introduction. “Great detail!” sat next to a paragraph I already suspected was irrelevant. At the bottom, my peer-review partner wrote, “Would love to read more.”

The draft was already over the word limit.

She handed it back looking pleased, and I thanked her. Then I went home with the same question I had brought to class: which part of this essay should go?

We are reviewing each other's next drafts on Thursday. I could ask for blunt criticism, but I do not want to make kindness sound like a failure. I also remember being afraid that an honest comment would damage somebody's confidence.

I am thinking of putting one request at the top: “Please mark the first place you lose track of my argument, even if you like the writing.” It gives her permission to notice a problem without requiring her to judge the entire paper.

I will still need to return the favor. Last week I wrote “nice flow” on her draft, which is apparently what happens when two nervous people exchange homework and try to remain friends.

Discussion

5 community replies

“Which paragraph would you cut if this were yours?” gives her a real decision instead of asking her to become generally harsher.

You could mark your own suspected cut first and ask whether she would miss it. That is a manageable place to start the exchange.

A pleasant reading experience and a clear argument are different things. Her compliments may be sincere while leaving your actual problem untouched.

Your admission about “nice flow” makes this easier to repair together. Neither person has to become the designated bad reviewer.

Did the instructor give reviewers specific questions, or just tell everyone to exchange drafts? The assignment may have left both of you guessing.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Education

Explore more Education stories →