Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Family ·

My parents expect grandchildren to fund the family scholarship from birthday money

Family category photographFamily

At a birthday lunch, Dad collected envelopes from the grandchildren and announced that ten percent would go to the new family scholarship.

The scholarship is meant to help future students. The children had not been told their gifts included a contribution.

My twelve-year-old wanted to donate after hearing the idea. Her cousin did not, and was called less community-minded.

We returned every envelope and invited relatives to contribute openly from their own money. Children may choose an amount after receiving their gifts.

Dad says automatic giving teaches generosity before selfish habits form. Generosity requires a giver who can say no.

A scholarship can carry the family name without treating every child’s birthday as its collection point.

Discussion

5 community replies

Return the full gifts first, then invite optional donations separately with no public list of which children contribute.

The child who declines should not be compared with the child who donates after hearing the purpose.

Your father may want generosity to become a normal family habit. Automatic deductions teach compliance more clearly than choice.

The birthday envelopes became a collection mechanism before the children knew a fund existed.

Will adults publish how the scholarship is managed before asking anyone for money?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Family

Explore more Family stories →