Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Family ·

My mother created an annual award for the “best” in-law

Family category photographFamily

At New Year’s lunch, Mum presented a trophy labeled “In-Law of the Year.” My sister’s husband won.

She scored attendance, hosting help, calls and how well each partner joined family traditions. Nobody knew there was a competition.

The winner was embarrassed. My spouse wondered which absences had counted against him while caring for his own parents.

We asked Mum to retire the trophy. She says recognition motivates people and gives in-laws a way to know what the family values.

A family can thank someone for a specific kindness. Ranking partners turns belonging into performance before judges they did not choose.

The trophy now sits in Mum’s cupboard. That is the only category it needs.

Discussion

5 community replies

Retire the trophy and replace it, if Mum wishes, with specific thanks that do not compare relatives.

The winner’s embarrassment shows that even first place can feel like participation in an unwanted system.

She may be trying to make in-laws feel seen and provide positive feedback. Secret scoring creates insecurity instead of belonging.

A cupboard is an appropriate final home for an award that made affection look competitive.

Were the criteria ever discussed with the people being judged, or did Mum infer them from her own expectations?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Family

Explore more Family stories →