Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Relationships ·

My girlfriend says maybe we should break up whenever we have an argument, then says she never means it

Relationships category photographRelationships

We were arguing about whose turn it was to drive when she said, ‘Maybe we just don't work.’

I stopped talking about the car. For the next hour, we discussed whether we should be together. By the end she was crying, I was reassuring her, and neither of us knew who was driving.

This has happened four times in six months. Afterward she says she panics and imagines the worst. She does not want to leave; she wants to know I still want her.

I believe that. I have started keeping a small mental bag packed anyway.

Last night I told her I would take the next breakup suggestion seriously. She asked whether that was a threat. I said I could not keep treating the future of the relationship as a phrase we use until an ordinary argument disappears.

She asked what she was supposed to say when she felt afraid. I suggested those exact words. She said fear does not come out so neatly.

I do not expect neatness. I want us to be allowed a disagreement about driving without losing the place we are supposed to drive home to.

Discussion

5 community replies

The mental bag is the cost. Even if she returns to feeling secure afterward, he remains partly prepared for the next announcement. Her intention does not make that preparation disappear.

Has she acknowledged that he stays afraid after she feels better? That seems more important than whether she can produce the perfect sentence while upset.

Agree during a calm moment that breakup discussions happen deliberately, outside a fight about something else. If she feels afraid mid-argument, they can pause without requiring him to prove the whole relationship again.

The original subject also needs a return time. Otherwise a pause after the breakup phrase may still make the driving disagreement vanish, preserving the same pattern with quieter words.

‘I'll take it seriously next time’ can sound like a warning that one bad sentence will end everything. He should explain what taking it seriously means rather than leaving her to imagine a punishment.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Relationships

Explore more Relationships stories →