Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Sports ·

My fantasy trade was fair until the player had one great Sunday

Sports category photographSports

Our fantasy football league allows trades without a league vote. The commissioner steps in only if there is collusion. We agreed to that before the draft because the old voting system had become a popularity contest.

On Thursday I traded a reliable running back for a receiver who had disappointed me all season. I needed help at receiver; the other manager needed someone who would actually start at running back. We both wrote 'deal' in the chat.

On Sunday, the receiver had a huge game. By dinner, three managers wanted the trade reversed. One said the other manager had been taken advantage of. That manager replied that he understood the deal and still wanted the running back. Nobody seemed interested in his answer.

The commissioner asked whether I would voluntarily unwind it 'for league harmony.' If I refuse, I become the person choosing a transaction over friendships. If I agree, every trade is apparently provisional until everyone has seen the next score.

I offered to talk through why we made the deal. Someone replied with the receiver's point total again.

I am leaving the player in my lineup. For a league that wanted less voting, we have developed a surprisingly loud unofficial ballot.

Discussion

4 community replies

If Thursday's deal raised no concern until Sunday's points appeared, the objection sounds like regret about the outcome rather than evidence of collusion.

One big game also does not settle who benefited over the rest of the season. Reversing it now would replace one uncertain decision with another, only after giving the loudest managers extra information.

Did anyone object before the game? An earlier complaint would not automatically justify reversal, but it would change the picture of people reacting only to the score.

The other manager saying he still wants the running back should carry some weight. Everyone is defending him while refusing to let him make his own choice.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Sports

Explore more Sports stories →