Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Parenting ·

My daughter told a child they could not both be her best friend

Parenting category photographParenting

At the playground, my five-year-old told one child she could be her best friend on Tuesdays. The child standing beside her asked what day she got.

My daughter said she hadn't decided.

I said, much too brightly, that everyone could be best friends. Both children looked at me. My daughter said that wasn't how best worked.

She's not wrong about the word. I don't think I'm going to settle this by redefining it loudly beside the slide.

The child waiting for a day went back to playing. My daughter followed and began explaining her schedule again. This time the child said she didn't want a day.

I asked my daughter to stop assigning one. She said she was trying to make it fair.

At home she drew three people and asked whether she was allowed to like one person most. I said having a feeling wasn't the same as announcing who had earned which place. She asked if keeping it secret was lying.

I hadn't expected the afternoon to turn into that question.

I don't want to require equal affection, or send her back with a polished speech she doesn't understand. I do want the other children to be able to play without waiting for her to publish the standings.

Tomorrow, if she starts allocating weekdays again, what would you actually say beside the slide?

Discussion

5 community replies

Beside the slide, keep it about the action: the other child said she doesn't want a day, so stop offering her one. The larger friendship question can wait until you're home.

Does she think a best friend is an agreement you make together, or a position one person gives out? Her calendar sounds like the second.

Telling her everyone is equally special might make the explanation harder. She can notice that she prefers someone's company without having to turn that into a public ranking.

And a private preference doesn't tell you what the other child has agreed to. That distinction fits the playground incident better than arguing over the definition of best.

The child who declined a day gave a pretty clear answer. Let that answer remain the end of the offer rather than another problem your daughter must solve for her.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Parenting

Explore more Parenting stories →