Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Education ·

My daughter got the answer right and refused to show how she found it

Education category photographEducation

The answer was 144. My daughter knew it, the calculator agreed, and she could not understand why the worksheet wanted three more lines.

“They asked how many tiles,” she said. “There are 144 tiles.”

I started telling her that teachers need to see her work. She asked whether I showed my work when I calculated the grocery bill. That was an irritatingly good question.

The assignment was about comparing methods, which I noticed only after we had spent ten minutes defending our positions. She had multiplied the two dimensions in her head. The directions asked for a drawing and an explanation of how it matched the multiplication.

Once we read that together, the extra lines had a purpose beyond proving she had obeyed. She still thought the drawing was unnecessary for this problem. I could see her point without treating the instruction as optional.

We sent the teacher a question about what she should explain when a step happens mentally. I am glad we asked. I am less glad that my first argument was essentially “because school.”

Discussion

5 community replies

The grocery-bill question deserved the pause it got. She was challenging the purpose, not necessarily refusing to think.

“What did you multiply, and why those numbers?” would capture the mental step without inventing several lines of arithmetic she never used.

The task had two goals: finding the number and connecting a drawing to the calculation. Reading the directions changed which disagreement you were having.

She can understand the purpose and still find the drawing tedious. A successful conversation does not require her to decide the assignment is wonderful.

Yes. “I see why we are doing this” and “I like doing this” are a lot to demand at once over one worksheet.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Education

Explore more Education stories →