My daughter did the kind thing before anyone could give her a sticker
ParentingWe made a little kindness chart for our two children. It was meant to be fun. By Wednesday, my eight-year-old was asking whether moving a chair counted as one act or two.
Then her younger brother spilled a box of crayons. She helped collect them while I was upstairs.
At dinner she asked for a sticker. I said I hadn't seen it. Her brother said she'd helped. I said we couldn't put a sticker on for every claim.
My daughter asked whether she should have left the crayons until I came down.
I had no answer that made my chart look as useful as it had looked on Sunday.
I'm not claiming one awkward evening establishes anything about reward systems in general. In our kitchen, we'd made a game where an adult's witnessing had become more important than the thing we said we wanted to notice.
Her brother offered to spill the crayons again. That was when I took the chart off the fridge.
The children weren't pleased. They'd counted their spaces and expected to finish. I can't announce that the whole arrangement is silly after inviting them to take it seriously, then expect no complaint.
We're deciding how to finish the game we started without requiring a demonstration of yesterday's help. My daughter wants her brother's account accepted. On the facts we actually have, that seems a reasonable place to begin.