Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Parenting ·

My daughter asked what was wrong with her drawing and did not want another lovely

Parenting category photographParenting

My ten-year-old showed me a drawing of a running cat. I said it was lovely.

She asked why the back leg looked strange.

I said it didn't.

She turned the page around and asked whether I could actually look at it.

I could see what she meant. One leg didn't seem connected in the way she'd intended. I had been so determined not to discourage her that I had denied a problem she was already trying to solve.

She wasn't asking me to judge whether she should draw. She wanted another pair of eyes on this cat.

I'm not an art teacher. I can describe what I notice and ask what she was trying to show. I don't need to invent expertise about anatomy or prescribe a technique I can't explain.

We looked at the drawing together. I pointed to the place my eye got confused. She said that was the bit she'd been asking about.

Then she tried a change on a separate piece of paper. I resisted announcing that it was perfect now.

She still didn't like it.

Would you ask at the start whether a child wants a response, help looking at one part, or simply to show you something? That sounds useful, but I don't want every drawing to arrive with a menu of adult services.

Yesterday she brought another page and put her finger beside the cat.

“Same question,” she said.

That may be enough of an introduction.

Discussion

5 community replies

She had already supplied the specific request. For this drawing, you didn't need a new opening system so much as an answer about the leg.

You can say what looks confusing without presenting it as an expert correction. Noticing and knowing the solution aren't the same thing.

That also gives her room to reject your observation or try a different change. Another pair of eyes doesn't have to become another person directing the drawing.

When she brings other work, does she usually ask about a part, or was this request different from her normal show-and-tell?

The repeated lovely probably felt less reassuring once she knew you could see the part she meant. Looking properly took her concern seriously.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Parenting

Explore more Parenting stories →