My daughter asked us to stop telling the funny story about how we named her
ParentingAt dinner, my brother asked how we'd chosen my twelve-year-old's name. I began the family story about the three names we'd rejected.
My daughter said, “Can we do the short version?”
I laughed and continued. The long version includes a name we now find ridiculous and a joke about the one her grandfather couldn't pronounce. Everyone usually enjoys it.
My daughter put down her fork. She said the story always made her feel like she'd narrowly avoided being a family mistake.
That wasn't what I meant. I wanted to tell her she was chosen carefully and give the room a few funny details. She had heard those details many more times than this particular audience had.
I said we'd picked a name we loved, and stopped there.
Afterward I asked whether she wanted the whole story retired. She said I could tell it when she wasn't sitting through it, but not use the rejected name as a nickname afterward. I had done that once or twice, thinking I was extending the joke.
I don't know whether she'll feel differently later. For now her request is quite specific. I can stop giving her the comic part every time somebody asks an ordinary question.
My brother messaged to ask which name he'd forgotten. I told him the short version was the one we were using. He remembered the actual name perfectly well.