My brother repaid a $300 cash loan with $300 in restaurant gift cards
MoneyI lent my brother $300 when his car needed a repair. Four months later, he handed me four restaurant gift cards totaling $300 and said the debt was settled.
He had earned the cards through work and could not exchange them for cash. I could use all four restaurants, but I had expected the money back in checking for a utility bill.
We compromised: I accepted two cards worth $150, and he sent $150 in cash over the next two paychecks. The other cards stayed with him.
The face values matched the loan. The timing and usefulness did not.
Was refusing half the cards unfair, or was cash always part of what ‘repay’ meant?