I wrote a fake ending inside a borrowed novel, and my friend defended it for years
Stories & ConfessionsMara lent me a mystery novel in college and warned me not to spoil the ending. I finished first, wrote “the gardener did it” on a scrap of paper and tucked it near the final chapter. The gardener was innocent. Mara found my note, got annoyed and stopped reading with thirty pages left. For twelve years she has used that “terrible gardener reveal” as her example of a lazy ending. Last weekend the author appeared at our local festival. Mara told him, to his face, why she hated his book. He looked completely baffled, then offered to sign a fresh copy so she could finally finish it. I slipped out of the line before either of them looked at me.