I warned my class about the ending and accidentally told them what happened
Education“Do not read the last paragraph yet,” I said, “because that is where you find out he never sent the letter.”
Twenty-four faces looked up. One student slowly closed the book.
I had spent the morning planning a lesson about how the author withholds information. Then I withheld it for approximately zero seconds.
There was no way to make the class unhear the sentence. I admitted what I had done and asked them to mark the earlier details they now read differently. It became a lesson about rereading, which was useful but was not the first reading I had meant to give them.
Afterward, a student said she liked finding those clues but wished she could have guessed the ending herself. I told her that was fair.
My lesson notes now have a large box around “say only the page number.” It is not an elegant teaching insight. It is the instruction I apparently needed before teaching suspense.