I Wanted Dessert, but Not Half of Yours
FoodWhen the server asked about dessert, my friend said, “We'll split the brownie.”
I had been reading about the lemon tart. I was full enough that ordering a whole dessert felt excessive, but I still wanted the sharp lemon and the crumbly edge in the photograph.
I said the brownie sounded good. It did sound good. That was the trap. Agreeing did not require me to say anything untrue, just to leave out what I preferred.
Two forks arrived. My friend happily broke the brownie down the middle. I ate my half and kept glancing at the next table, where somebody had ordered the tart.
On the walk home, she said sharing had been the perfect amount. I said yes. Then I finally mentioned that I had wanted the lemon one.
“Why didn't you get it?”
I had no answer that would survive being spoken aloud. We had not made a pact to share. I had simply heard one suggestion and treated it as a group decision.
The next time we go back, I may still order something small. But I am going to choose it before volunteering to want half a brownie.