Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Education ·

I lost points by answering the optional question I wanted to show off on

Education category photographEducation

I had finished the required questions with twelve minutes left. The final page said the challenge problem was optional. I turned back three pages and crossed out a correct answer so I could reuse the space for it.

When the exam came back, the challenge earned nothing and the crossed-out answer stayed crossed out.

The instructor had not promised that optional meant consequence-free. I had simply decided that attempting the hardest thing must improve the impression my paper made.

I keep wanting to argue that she should know I understood the earlier question. The work was there, beneath a line I put through it. I need to ask how she treats crossed-out responses before claiming she marked it unfairly.

What bothers me most is that I abandoned something complete in order to look more capable. I would have advised any friend to use a fresh page and ask about the rules. Alone at that desk, I apparently preferred a dramatic gesture.

Discussion

5 community replies

The optional question did not demand the crossed-out answer as an entry fee. That was a separate decision you made under the same excitement.

Was there an instruction about which attempt would be marked? Check that before the conversation becomes a debate about what the instructor should infer.

And separate the challenge rules from the crossed-out-work rule. “Optional” may answer the first question without answering the second.

You can be disappointed about the score without turning this into evidence that ambition itself was foolish. The paper-handling choice is specific and changeable.

Bring the actual page when you ask. A visible crossed-out solution is easier to discuss accurately than a remembered account of what you meant.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Education

Explore more Education stories →