Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Education ·

I gave the neat notebook the higher mark before I noticed the missing explanation

Education category photographEducation

The first notebook had color-coded headings, straight margins, and a diagram I could have put under the document camera. The second had crossed-out arrows and a coffee-colored ring on the back cover.

I was halfway through marking the second when I realized it answered the question the first student had avoided.

This was a short assessment in my class, not a notebook-beauty contest. I had written the criteria myself. Still, I had let the ease of reading the first book become a feeling that its reasoning must be better.

I went back and compared both against the same prompt. The messy explanation needed work. The neat one needed more.

Now I am checking the rest before returning anything. I want students to make their thinking readable, but “readable” cannot quietly expand to “looks like a person who has everything together.”

The student with the untidy book asked whether she should recopy it. I told her to wait. The person who needed to redo something first was me.

Discussion

5 community replies

Checking the same criterion across all the notebooks before moving to the next could help expose where presentation is influencing the comparison.

Telling her to wait prevents her spending an evening polishing work before you have identified what actually needs revision.

Legibility can matter if the reasoning cannot be followed. The issue is distinguishing that obstacle from a preference for tidy pages.

Would a second reader reach the same difficulty with the crossed-out arrows? That might help separate readability from first impression.

The question about recopying shows what she expected the feedback to be. The comments you return could make the distinction clearer than the score alone.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Education

Explore more Education stories →