I gave the neat notebook the higher mark before I noticed the missing explanation
EducationThe first notebook had color-coded headings, straight margins, and a diagram I could have put under the document camera. The second had crossed-out arrows and a coffee-colored ring on the back cover.
I was halfway through marking the second when I realized it answered the question the first student had avoided.
This was a short assessment in my class, not a notebook-beauty contest. I had written the criteria myself. Still, I had let the ease of reading the first book become a feeling that its reasoning must be better.
I went back and compared both against the same prompt. The messy explanation needed work. The neat one needed more.
Now I am checking the rest before returning anything. I want students to make their thinking readable, but “readable” cannot quietly expand to “looks like a person who has everything together.”
The student with the untidy book asked whether she should recopy it. I told her to wait. The person who needed to redo something first was me.