Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Parenting ·

I gave him book-fair money and he bought a pencil

Parenting category photographParenting

My eight-year-old came out of the school book fair carrying a pencil shaped like a carrot. There was no book in his bag.

I asked why he'd wasted the money. He said he'd chosen something he liked and brought the change home.

I'd told him he could spend five dollars at the fair. In my head that meant a book. The little envelope I handed him said book fair, which I now wanted to treat as a much longer set of instructions.

He'd looked at the books. The one he wanted cost more than the amount he'd brought, and he didn't want the others. The carrot pencil was inside his budget.

I still wish the fair hadn't become a place where the thing he most wanted was stationery. That opinion doesn't change the choice I actually offered him.

He asked whether I wanted him to return it. I said no, I shouldn't have called it a waste after he'd followed the limit we'd discussed.

Next time I can decide whether I'm offering money for a book or money to choose something at the fair. He may have a different answer to each offer.

For now the pencil is on his desk. He has drawn a rabbit beside it. I haven't asked the rabbit to demonstrate educational value before I let him enjoy the purchase.

Discussion

5 community replies

You can dislike the selection of extras at a book fair. That concern belongs with the adults arranging purchases, rather than becoming a rule your son should have inferred from the envelope.

Did he know he could bring all the money home if he didn't find a book? It sounds as though he made a considered choice, but the available options matter to the next conversation.

Say what the money is for before the next fair. A book-only offer is different from a small spending budget, and he should get to know which one he's accepting.

Include whether he may save it or needs to return unused money. That is easier to establish ahead of time than after seeing the object he chose.

He brought back the change and still found himself defending the purchase. Withdrawing “waste” lets the original care he took remain part of the account.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Parenting

Explore more Parenting stories →