Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Education ·

I checked the answer box before I listened to the child reading it

Education category photographEducation

My student pointed at the second sentence and read it aloud. I was looking at the answer key on my lap and said, “Try again.”

She did. I said it once more.

Then I looked at her page. Our copies had different pictures. The sentence she was reading made sense with hers.

I volunteer in an after-school reading group. I am meant to help children notice the words and explain what they understand. For those two turns, I had listened only for the response I expected.

I told her I had the wrong page, showed her the difference, and asked what she had noticed in her picture. She answered quickly, then asked whether we could stop using the key.

We still needed the teaching materials, but I put my copy where we could both see which page it was. I also checked with the group leader about keeping the sets together.

She resumed reading. The repeated attempt had not been hers to make.

Discussion

5 community replies

Showing the different pictures gave her something concrete to understand. Otherwise “my mistake” could still leave her unsure which answer was right.

Her request to stop using the key makes sense after being corrected twice for something she could see was working.

Matching page identifiers before the next session would address the material mix-up. Listening to the child’s explanation addresses the separate assumption you made.

Both changes matter. A perfectly matched set would not, by itself, prevent an adult from correcting before looking.

Did she tell you why the sentence fitted before you saw the page? It may be worth noticing what information was available but unheard.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Education

Explore more Education stories →