I broke the racket my opponent lent me, then won the match with it
SportsMy spare tennis racket was at home when a string snapped during warmup. The player on the other side of the net opened his bag and offered me one of his.
We were playing a local ladder match. I thanked him, hit a few balls, and thought that borrowing from my opponent was unusually civilized.
At 4–4 in the second set I chased a low ball and scraped the frame hard against the court. The racket still played, and I won in a third-set tiebreak. When I handed it back, we both saw a chip near the edge. I said I would pay to have someone assess it. He said not to worry.
That evening he sent a link to a new racket costing $219. His message said he would not trust the damaged one in a match.
I do not know whether the chip is cosmetic or worse. I also do not want to become the person who borrows equipment, wins, and then argues about how cheaply generosity should be reimbursed. The racket was visibly used when he lent it, but it was usable.
I offered to take it to his usual shop and pay for an assessment first. He replied, 'I was trying to do you a favor.'
He did. I just cannot tell whether repaying that favor means accepting his replacement price without another question.