Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
Parenting ·

I asked for a birthday wish list and then called the list greedy

Parenting category photographParenting

My nine-year-old wrote twelve things on his birthday list. Two were expensive. Several were small.

I told him he couldn't expect all that.

He said I'd asked what he wished for.

I had. I even told him to think broadly because grandparents had asked for ideas.

Then I read the page as if he had submitted an invoice.

He crossed out the two expensive things. I said he didn't have to cross them out, just understand that he wouldn't get everything. He asked whether the page was supposed to contain wishes or things we had already decided to buy.

There was an answer available, but I had not supplied it before asking for the list.

We talked about the difference between an idea somebody can choose and a promise about what will arrive. I didn't make him add inexpensive items to demonstrate a suitably grateful personality.

He put one crossed-out thing back. The other stayed crossed out because, he said, he'd thought of something better.

The page is now on the fridge. It contains possibilities, not instructions for twelve separate purchases.

I still need to tell relatives what we actually mean when we pass it along. Otherwise I'll explain uncertainty to him and present the adults with a strangely authoritative shopping document.

His last entry is “something I haven't thought of.”

I'm glad there is still room for that after all the discussion I created about wanting things.

Discussion

3 community replies

Wishes or approved purchases was a fair question. You'd asked for the first and judged him as though he'd demanded the second.

Did he ever say he expected every item, or did that expectation come from how the adults read the page?

You can be clear about limits without calling the ideas greedy. A list can include something unlikely while remaining a list of possibilities.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in Parenting

Explore more Parenting stories →