Everyone assumed the polished paragraph was mine. I had written the rough one.
EducationOur seminar compared two anonymous paragraphs on the screen. The instructor asked which one sounded more convincing.
Several people chose the smooth one. Then a student said the rougher paragraph “sounded like someone hiding behind big words.” Everybody laughed at a sentence I had spent Sunday trying to simplify.
Neither paragraph had a name attached. Nobody was attacking me knowingly. That did not make it easy to sit there and hear my draft treated as evidence of a personality problem.
When the instructor asked what we would change, I knew the answer. The example in the third sentence did not support the claim. I said that, and the room finally began discussing something I could use.
Afterward, I told the instructor the paragraph was mine and that the guessing about its author had been hard to hear. She said the exercise was meant to address the writing. I believe her.
I do not want the class to stop examining weak drafts. Mine was weak. I want us to be able to say what a sentence fails to do without deciding what sort of person wrote it.