AITA for withholding a cleaner’s invoice after she broke my vase?
AITAA cleaner knocked a small vase from my bathroom shelf. She left a note, photographed the pieces and included her $140 invoice for the visit.
The vase had cost $60 years ago. I withheld the entire cleaning payment and told her the difference covered inconvenience and the time needed to find a replacement.
She offered to deduct $60 or replace it with the same model she found online. I refused because the listing required shipping and the vase had sentimental value from my first apartment.
She says an accident did not make four hours of completed work free. I say professionals should be responsible for damage inside a client’s home.
My service agreement allows documented damage to be offset against an invoice but does not mention inconvenience. I had no appraisal showing the vase was worth more than its purchase price.
The bathroom is clean. The invoice remains unpaid, and the replacement listing has since sold.