Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for withdrawing a family’s dog-adoption application after they renamed the dog early?

AITA category photographAITA

I volunteer with a small dog rescue and foster a terrier called Mabel. A family completed two visits and seemed like a strong match. The final home check was still pending.

After the second visit, they posted pictures of Mabel online under the name “Pepper” and wrote that their new dog was coming home Saturday. They also ordered a tag with that name.

I told them the adoption was not final and asked them to remove the post. They did within an hour and apologized, saying their children were excited.

I recommended that the rescue reject their application. I said announcing ownership before approval showed poor boundaries and could create pressure on volunteers. Another family adopted Mabel the following week.

The first family learned of it and complained to the rescue director. They had passed their references and had a fenced yard. The director says I should have documented the concern but allowed the home check to decide.

I had grown attached to Mabel and disliked the new name. I told myself those feelings made me especially alert, not biased.

Mabel is settled elsewhere. The first family’s children had already drawn a welcome sign for Pepper.

Discussion

5 community replies

Announcing an unfinished adoption as final can pressure a rescue and mislead children, so correcting the family was appropriate.

They removed the post promptly and otherwise passed screening. Rejection turned one premature celebration into proof they could not provide a good home.

The foster’s attachment and dislike of the new name do not prove the decision was biased, but they were conflicts worth disclosing to the director.

Did the rescue have a written rule against public posts or renaming before approval, and were applicants told that rule?

Ask the rescue to separate foster observations from final approval and to give applicants a clear no-announcement policy before visits begin.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →