Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for using my nephew’s drawings on my restaurant menu?

AITA category photographAITA

My nine-year-old nephew drew cartoon vegetables while waiting at my restaurant. I loved them and scanned five drawings for the children’s menu.

His parents discovered the menus weeks later. They say I should have asked before using his art in a business and that he deserves payment.

I gave him a $50 art-store voucher and put his first name in small print. They want a share of the menu redesign fee I would otherwise have paid an illustrator.

I say the drawings were made at my table, left behind and used as a loving family detail. My nephew says he is proud of the carrot but embarrassed by the tomato, which he wanted to redraw.

Ten thousand menus have already been printed. Removing one drawing would require reprinting all of them.

The voucher remains unused because his parents say accepting it might imply agreement.

Discussion

5 community replies

A child leaving drawings at a family table did not grant commercial-use permission or waive creative approval.

His pride in one drawing and embarrassment about another show why approval should be specific, not all-or-nothing.

The credit and voucher recognized him after the fact, but neither substituted for consent before a large print run.

Can future menus replace the unwanted tomato without discarding the current stock immediately?

Agree on fair payment with his parents and let your nephew approve every drawing in the next print edition.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →