Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for using my daughter’s savings to replace her broken school laptop?

AITA category photographAITA

My sixteen-year-old dropped her school-issued laptop while carrying it without the protective case. The school charged $450 for replacement.

She had $600 saved from a summer job for a music festival. I transferred $450 from her youth account and paid the school without asking.

She says I controlled the account only because she was a minor and had no right to redirect wages she earned. I say the damage resulted from ignoring a clear case rule and should not become a household expense.

The school offered a payment plan and community-service option. I knew about both but chose immediate payment because I did not want an outstanding balance.

The festival tickets sold out before she could rebuild her savings. She now keeps new earnings in cash with her aunt.

The laptop is replaced. The lesson she says she learned is not about carrying cases.

Discussion

4 community replies

Ignoring the protective-case rule created a reasonable basis for your daughter to bear some replacement responsibility.

Immediate payment simplified the balance for you but caused the irreversible loss of sold-out festival access for her.

You took most of her earned savings without consent even though installment and service options could have preserved choice.

Had you previously agreed that accidental school-property costs could be withdrawn from the youth account?

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →