Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for throwing away my roommate’s sourdough starter after it leaked in the refrigerator?

AITA category photographAITA

My roommate kept a sourdough starter in a glass jar on the top refrigerator shelf. She had maintained it for six years and called it “June.”

While she was away for ten days, the starter overflowed. Sticky liquid ran down two shelves and into the vegetable drawer. I texted her photographs and asked what to do.

She replied six hours later, saying to move a spoonful into a clean jar and discard the rest. By then, I had thrown away the entire contents and washed the jar because the smell made me nauseated.

She says I knew the starter was living culture and could have saved it in under a minute. I say I did not know whether the overflow was safe and was not going to keep spoiled-looking food in a shared refrigerator.

There was no visible mold. I did not search for guidance or wait for her response because I wanted the refrigerator clean before my groceries arrived.

Another baker has offered her some starter descended from the same original batch, but she says six years of her own routine cannot be handed back in a different jar.

The refrigerator is spotless. My roommate now labels everything with disposal instructions, including food that has never leaked.

Discussion

5 community replies

A large leak through a shared refrigerator needed prompt cleanup, and the roommate should have used a larger container before leaving.

The narrator did not need to become a fermentation expert; moving a small sample to a clean container was the low-risk middle option.

There was no visible mold, and saving one spoonful would have preserved the starter while allowing the same immediate cleanup.

Had your roommate previously explained how to feed or preserve the starter during trips, or did she leave without any care plan?

Help obtain the related starter, replace any supplies and agree on sealed secondary containers for future shared-fridge projects.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →