Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for telling our family that my sister never paid the restaurant deposit?

AITA category photographAITA

My sister organized our mother’s birthday dinner and collected $50 from each of eight relatives for a restaurant deposit.

The restaurant canceled our reservation the morning of the dinner, saying no deposit had been received. My sister told the family chat that the restaurant had lost the payment and began demanding an immediate refund.

I had helped her compare venues and knew she had missed the payment link deadline. I posted a screenshot of her earlier message admitting she forgot.

She says I humiliated her while she was trying to salvage the birthday. I say blaming the restaurant could have harmed staff who had done nothing wrong.

We found another venue, but it cost more. My sister used the collected money toward that bill and covered the difference herself.

I could have corrected her privately first. I posted the screenshot because several relatives had praised her for “standing up to the restaurant,” and I wanted the record fixed before the story settled.

Our mother got her dinner. Every toast avoided the word “organized.”

Discussion

5 community replies

Your sister falsely blamed the restaurant for a missed payment, so allowing the accusation to spread unchecked was unfair to staff.

Correcting the facts was appropriate; the question is whether the screenshot and timing were necessary to do it.

Posting the screenshot before a private correction prioritized public exposure while she was actively finding a replacement venue.

Had anyone contacted or reviewed the restaurant publicly, or was the accusation still confined to the family chat?

Acknowledge that you should have messaged her first, while maintaining that the restaurant could not be used as the excuse.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →