Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for telling my nieces about their move before my brother did?

AITA category photographAITA

My brother told me privately that he had accepted a job across the country. He and his spouse planned to tell their daughters after the school talent show so the children could enjoy the week.

Two days before the show, my fourteen-year-old niece asked why her parents were browsing houses on a shared tablet. She looked frightened and asked whether they were moving.

I told her the truth and said the job was good news. She immediately told her younger sister, and both confronted their parents that evening.

My brother says I took away their chance to explain the move together and burdened the girls before a performance they had practiced for months. I say lying to a direct question would have damaged my niece’s trust.

I could have said she needed to ask her parents and called my brother immediately. I answered because I wanted her to hear a calm version rather than imagine something worse.

The girls still performed, but the younger one cried backstage. My brother and his spouse no longer share plans with me before announcing them.

My niece says she is glad I did not lie. She also says she wishes her parents had been in the room.

Discussion

5 community replies

A teenager who found house listings had a real concern, and inventing a denial could have damaged trust.

Her relief that you did not lie does not mean she preferred learning the full news without her parents there.

You had a truthful alternative—directing her to her parents—and knew they planned a careful conversation only days later.

Could you have called or messaged your brother while your niece was present before answering?

Apologize for disclosing the move, while explaining that future secrets involving children need an agreed response to direct questions.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →