AITA for telling my employee that customers complained when only one person did?
AITAI manage a small café. One employee, Jay, sings quietly while cleaning tables. Most customers ignore it, and a few regulars enjoy it.
Last week, one customer asked whether I could make him stop. She said she wanted a peaceful breakfast. I told Jay, “Customers have complained about the singing, so it needs to end.”
Jay stopped completely. He later asked two regulars whether they had complained, and they told him they liked the music. He then asked me how many complaints there were. I admitted there had been one.
He says I invented a crowd so he would not question my preference. I say one complaint is still customer feedback, and saying “customers” protected the person’s identity.
The customer had not requested anonymity; I added that concern afterward. The truth is that I sometimes found the singing distracting too and wanted a simple reason to stop it.
The café is quieter now. Jay completes his tasks but no longer chats with guests or volunteers for closing shifts.
I solved a small management problem by making him feel watched by a room that had mostly been on his side.