Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for taking tools from my late aunt’s shed before my cousins inventoried it?

AITA category photographAITA

After my aunt died, my cousins asked me to photograph the contents of her garden shed because I lived nearby. They planned to inventory the estate the following weekend.

While taking pictures, I found a set of woodworking tools my aunt had borrowed from my father years ago. He had died before asking for them back. I took the tools home.

At the inventory, my cousins compared the photographs with the shed and noticed the empty shelf. I explained that the tools had always belonged to my father.

They say the estate representative should have decided that after seeing proof. I have an old photograph of my father using one tool, but no receipt or loan message.

One cousin wanted the set because my aunt had taught her woodworking with it. I offered to lend it to her, which made her angrier.

I say returning family property to my side was different from claiming an inheritance. They say I was trusted to document the shed, not settle ownership alone.

The inventory now lists the tools as “removed before count.” My photographs are the evidence against the version of events I preferred.

Discussion

5 community replies

You were given access to document estate property and used that access to remove disputed items before the inventory.

Offering to lend the tools assumed the very ownership dispute the estate process was meant to resolve.

The tools may genuinely have originated with your father, but an old photograph does not establish that the later possession remained a loan.

Did any relative hear your aunt describe the tools as borrowed, gifted or inherited after your father died?

Return the set for inventory, submit the photograph as evidence and let the estate representative decide possession transparently.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →