AITA for taking back the handmade doll my daughter gave her friend?
AITAMy ten-year-old daughter sewed a cloth doll with my help. At a sleepover, she gave it to her friend Ava as a birthday present.
The next morning, my daughter cried and said she had only offered the doll because other children were watching. She wanted it back. I texted Ava’s mother, who said Ava had slept holding it and believed it was a real gift.
At school pickup, I asked Ava directly whether we could borrow the doll for a repair. When she handed it to me, I took it home and later told her mother we were keeping it.
I offered to buy Ava another doll. Her mother says I taught both children that a gift can be reclaimed through a trick whenever the giver regrets it.
My daughter says I protected something irreplaceable. She also admitted she never told Ava she wanted it returned because she was embarrassed.
I could have helped her ask honestly and accept Ava’s answer. Instead, I used an adult’s authority to solve the discomfort before either child had to speak plainly.
The handmade doll is back on my daughter’s shelf. Ava returned the store-bought replacement unopened.