Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for taking back the handmade doll my daughter gave her friend?

AITA category photographAITA

My ten-year-old daughter sewed a cloth doll with my help. At a sleepover, she gave it to her friend Ava as a birthday present.

The next morning, my daughter cried and said she had only offered the doll because other children were watching. She wanted it back. I texted Ava’s mother, who said Ava had slept holding it and believed it was a real gift.

At school pickup, I asked Ava directly whether we could borrow the doll for a repair. When she handed it to me, I took it home and later told her mother we were keeping it.

I offered to buy Ava another doll. Her mother says I taught both children that a gift can be reclaimed through a trick whenever the giver regrets it.

My daughter says I protected something irreplaceable. She also admitted she never told Ava she wanted it returned because she was embarrassed.

I could have helped her ask honestly and accept Ava’s answer. Instead, I used an adult’s authority to solve the discomfort before either child had to speak plainly.

The handmade doll is back on my daughter’s shelf. Ava returned the store-bought replacement unopened.

Discussion

5 community replies

A ten-year-old can regret giving away a handmade object under social pressure, and helping her discuss that feeling was appropriate.

Regret deserves empathy, but it does not automatically restore ownership once the recipient reasonably accepted a gift.

You obtained the doll through a false repair request after Ava’s mother had already said it was understood as a gift.

Did your daughter explicitly say “this is your birthday present,” or was the exchange ambiguous in front of the other children?

Return the doll and help your daughter ask Ava directly; let Ava decide whether friendship matters more to her than keeping it.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →