Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for taking back the gift after my child’s teacher transferred?

AITA category photographAITA

Parents collected money for a classroom tablet as an end-of-year gift for our teacher. We presented it two weeks early because the school announced she was transferring.

The next day, I learned the tablet had been purchased with my store account and was still within the return period. I asked the teacher to give it back, saying the gift was meant to benefit our classroom, not leave with her.

She returned it in front of the children. Several parents were upset because their notes had thanked her personally, not the classroom.

I say everyone contributed because she was teaching our children and that purpose ended with the transfer. They say a completed gift does not reverse when someone changes jobs.

I returned the tablet and kept the refund in the parent fund for next year. No group vote authorized that choice.

The teacher’s farewell card includes drawings of the tablet she held for one day.

Discussion

5 community replies

The group had already presented a personal farewell gift, and you unilaterally reclaimed it after ownership transferred.

Keeping the refund in a parent fund did not solve the lack of contributor consent or the public humiliation.

A costly device may have been intended partly for classroom use, but that condition needed to be explicit before presentation.

Did the collection message describe the tablet as teacher property or classroom equipment?

Poll contributors, reimburse or replace the gift and apologize to the teacher privately and in front of the class if appropriate.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →