Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Explore
AITA ·

AITA for signing a farewell card for a coworker who refused to participate?

AITA category photographAITA

Our department prepared a farewell card for a manager who was retiring. One coworker, Ben, declined to sign because the manager had denied him a promotion.

I coordinated the card and thought one missing name would look pointed. I wrote “Best wishes, Ben” in handwriting different from my own and added it among the signatures.

At the farewell lunch, the manager thanked Ben directly for the kind message. Ben said he had not signed anything. The room became quiet, and I admitted what I had done.

Ben says I forged his participation and made him look petty when the truth came out. I say the words were neutral and intended to keep a workplace event civil.

The manager later told me she had not noticed which names were missing until I created the confrontation.

I could have left blank space or signed only for myself. I decided appearances belonged to the group more than refusal belonged to the person making it.

The card is framed in the manager’s home. Ben’s false signature is still visible.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ben explicitly declined, and writing his name anyway falsely represented both participation and goodwill.

The manager’s failure to notice missing names shows the forgery created the awkwardness it was meant to prevent.

You wanted a calm retirement event, but neutrality would have meant leaving the choice alone rather than manufacturing agreement.

Had the manager or anyone else asked you to account for every employee’s signature?

Apologize to Ben without defending the wording and never sign another person’s name to collective messages.

Join the discussion

0 reader replies

More in AITA

Explore more AITA stories →